Skillet & Stove

Lodge vs Griswold: New Iron Against the Old Benchmark

The comparison everybody makes and almost nobody frames properly: one pan is in stock for the price of a takeaway, the other has not been made since 1957 and arrives as somebody else's problem. Here is what each actually gives you.

By Stephen V.Last updated How we pick

How this is funded: we earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which pan we recommend, and we’ll happily tell you to keep the skillet you already own. Full disclosure.

Buy the new Lodge.If you are standing at a flea market deciding whether a rusty Griswold at a collector price beats a classic 10.25-inch Lodge, the Lodge is the better purchase for almost everyone: it is in stock, it is pre-seasoned, Lodge publishes 5.36 lb for it, it carries the Made Right lifetime warranty, and it costs about the same as dinner. Buy the Griswold if you want a Griswold — because it is old, because of the mark on the bottom, because restoring it is the pleasure. That is a real reason. It is not a cooking reason, and the two get conflated constantly.

That said, the vintage camp is not wrong about the pan. A pre-war Griswold genuinely is thinner, lighter for its diameter, and smoother on the cooking surface than a modern classic Lodge. The argument this page makes is narrower than “old iron is a myth”: it is that every one of those advantages is now purchasable new, with a warranty and a published spec sheet, from companies you can email.

You cannot buy a Griswold, only a used one

This is the fact that reframes everything else and it is easy to skate past. Griswold has not been a going concern since 1957. The Wagner and Griswold Society’s own FAQ records the sequence: McGraw Edison bought Griswold on March 29, 1957, then sold it in December 1957 to Randall, which already owned Wagner — and from that point “all subsequent ‘Griswold’ pieces were made in the Wagner foundry in Sidney, Ohio,” pieces that do not say Erie on them. The society adds the collector verdict plainly: most collectors do not consider the Sidney pieces real Griswold, and almost any piece made after 1960 has limited collector appeal.

So the pan on the table in front of you was made somewhere between roughly 1880 and 1957, by a company that no longer exists, and it has had between seventy and a hundred and forty years of somebody else’s cooking. There is no warranty, no return, no spec sheet and no recourse. Everything below has to be read against that.

The comparison, on what is actually published

One honest note on this table before you read it: Lodge publishes a spec sheet and Griswold cannot. The vintage column therefore draws on the collectors’ own dated chart and the size tables the society links, which cover marks and measured dimensions — not weights, which nobody publishes for a 1920s casting.

What each side publishes. Griswold figures come from the Wagner and Griswold Society's dating chart and the size chart it links from its own educational page.
Lodge classic (new)Griswold (vintage, c1880–1957)
AvailabilityIn stock, nine sizes, every major retailerSecondhand only — out of production since 1957
Price bandBudgetSet by the secondhand market; concentrated in the earlier marks
Sizing systemStated in inches — 10.25 in, 12 in, 15 inLegacy numbers: No. 8 = 10.625 in top over an 8.875 in bottom; No. 10 = 11.75 in over 10 in
Published weight5.36 lb for the 10.25-inch, from Lodge's own figuresNot published by anyone — thinner castings, but no maker's number exists
Cooking surface as suppliedPebbled from the foundry; smooths over years of useMachined smooth, if the pan has not been pitted by rust
Condition on arrivalPre-seasoned, usable the day it arrivesUsually needs stripping and re-seasoning; the society maintains its own restoration guidance
Heat ringNone on the modern classicsCommon on earlier skillets — the society defines it as the small rim around the outside of the bottom
WarrantyLodge Made Right lifetime warrantyNone
DatingNot applicableSlant trademark with ERIE PA USA c1909–c1924; block trademark c1916–c1940; small trademark late 1930s–c1952; large trademark c1952–1957
RiskYou chose the wrong sizeWarping, hairline cracks, deep pitting, a reproduction, or a Sidney-era piece sold as Erie

A No. 8 is not a 10.25-inch pan

The single most practical thing on this page. Vintage numbers are not inches and never were, and buyers get caught by it constantly. The size chart the society links from its own educational page measures a No. 8 skillet at 10.625 inches across the top, over an 8.875-inch bottom, 2 inches deep. A No. 10 is 11.75 inches across a 10-inch bottom. A No. 6 is 9.125 inches. So a “No. 8” Griswold is a slightly larger pan than a classic 10.25-inch Lodge, and a “No. 10” is closer to a modern 12-inch than to a 10.

The system did not die with Griswold, either. Lancaster sells a No. 10 new today that measures 11.6 inches — within a sixth of an inch of the chart’s figure for a No. 10 made a century ago, which is a quietly remarkable piece of continuity. Field sells a No. 8 at 10.25 inches. If you are shopping across both markets, our guide to what the numbers on cast iron mean has the whole table and the reason the system exists at all.

Thin iron versus thick iron, which is the real difference

Strip away the romance and the substantive cooking distinction is wall thickness. Older pans were cast thinner. Thinner iron is lighter for a given diameter and responds faster when you turn the heat down. Thicker iron stores more energy, which means it barely flinches when four cold steaks land in it and it holds a temperature through a long bake.

Neither is better in the abstract. Thin iron suits a cook who adjusts heat constantly and wants to lift the pan one-handed; thick iron suits searing, big-batch cooking and anything you put in the oven. What has changed since 1957 is that you can now choose. Lodge’s Blacklock line is thin-walled on purpose — retailer listings put the 10.25-inch at 3.86 to 4.23 lb against the classic’s maker-published 5.36 lb, and Lodge does not publish a weight for it at all, which we say rather than paper over. We rank the whole registry on that axis in best lightweight cast iron skillets.

Smoothness: a solved problem

The other vintage talking point is the machined cooking surface, and it is true that a pre-war pan comes glassy where a classic Lodge comes pebbled. It is also true that it matters most in the first few months and progressively less after that, because seasoning is polymerized oil bonded to the iron — a layer that builds up and evens out whatever is underneath it. America’s Test Kitchen’s explainer on the chemistry and the American Chemical Society’s both describe the same process, and neither depends on how the metal was finished.

If you want smooth now, buy smooth now. Stargazer states its cooking surface is machined smooth after casting, in the USA, with a warranty that has no expiration date. Lancaster publishes an unusually large 10-inch flat surface on an 11.6-inch pan. Both cost a fraction of what they would if they were sixty years old, which is a funny sentence to write and an accurate one. The full field is in best smooth cast iron skillets.

What we would actually do

Buy the classic Lodge, cook in it for six months, and then decide whether what you want next is less weight, a smoother surface, or more flat area — because those are three different pans and the vintage market sells all three under one word. If you then want a Griswold, buy it with your eyes open: check the mark against the society’s dated chart, read its page on reproductions, and assume a restoration. Our Griswold identification guide exists for exactly that moment, and the vintage buying guide lists what to inspect before money changes hands.

Live prices for the four new pans above are in the table and refresh daily. We publish no prices for the secondhand market and will not estimate them — that is not a number anyone can honestly put on a page.

New pans that answer the vintage argument

Ranked on published specs, build and buyer fit. Select a row to jump to the full write-up. We haven’t cooked in all of these — here is exactly what we do instead.

#ProductBest forPrice
1
Lodge Classic 10.25-inch Skillet

Lodge Classic 10.25-inch Skillet

The pan most people should buy and stop thinking about. Pre-seasoned, made in the USA, oven-safe to anything, and about $25 — the value is so lopsided that the expensive pans have to justify themselves against it, not the other way around.

Best overall new pan
$24.90 · View on Amazon

Price as of October 11, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

2
Lodge Blacklock 10.25-inch Triple-Seasoned Skillet

Lodge Blacklock 10.25-inch Triple-Seasoned Skillet

Lodge's lightweight line — thinner walls and a triple layer of seasoning, aimed at people who love cast iron but hate hauling five pounds of it. Roughly a pound and a half lighter than the classic, at about double the price.

Closest on weight
$59.95 · View on Amazon

Price as of October 11, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

3
Stargazer 10.5-inch Cast Iron Skillet

Stargazer 10.5-inch Cast Iron Skillet

The everyday-size Stargazer, and the one most people who want a machined-smooth pan should look at first. Same polished surface, flared drip-free rim and long stay-cool handle as the 12-inch, in a 5.2 lb body that is barely heavier than a classic Lodge — which is the point.

Closest on surface finish
$155.00 · View on Amazon

Price as of October 11, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

4
Lancaster No. 10 Cast Iron Skillet (11.6-inch)

Lancaster No. 10 Cast Iron Skillet (11.6-inch)

A big, machined-smooth American pan with an unusually large 10-inch cooking surface for its class — more usable flat space than most 12-inch skillets. A specialist heirloom buy, not a first pan.

Closest on flat cooking area
$225.00 · View on Amazon

Price as of October 11, 2026. #ad How we’re funded

The picks in full

#1Best overall new pan

Lodge Classic 10.25-inch Skillet

The pan most people should buy and stop thinking about. Pre-seasoned, made in the USA, oven-safe to anything, and about $25 — the value is so lopsided that the expensive pans have to justify themselves against it, not the other way around.

Strengths

  • Around $25 for a lifetime pan — nothing else here is close on value
  • Made in the USA and sold pre-seasoned, so it cooks the day it arrives
  • Thick walls hold heat well for searing

Trade-offs

  • Slightly pebbled cooking surface (it smooths with years of use)
  • Short handle gets hot and gives little leverage for 5+ lb of iron
  • Heavier than the machined 'heirloom' pans
MaterialBare cast iron
Diameter10.25 in
Weight5.36 lb
Oven-safe toAny oven temp
Induction-readyYes
Made inUSA
WarrantyLifetime (Made Right)

Spec note. Lodge's published weight is 5.36 lb for the 10.25-inch. It ships pre-seasoned from the foundry, so it's usable immediately — you just keep the seasoning up. Bare iron has no upper oven-temperature limit.

Specs read from the manufacturer and product listing, on July 20, 2026. “Not published” means the maker doesn’t state that figure.

#2Closest on weight

Lodge Blacklock 10.25-inch Triple-Seasoned Skillet

Lodge's lightweight line — thinner walls and a triple layer of seasoning, aimed at people who love cast iron but hate hauling five pounds of it. Roughly a pound and a half lighter than the classic, at about double the price.

Strengths

  • Markedly lighter than the classic Lodge (about 3.9 lb)
  • Triple-seasoned from the factory for a smoother start
  • Still made in the USA, still a Lodge lifetime pan

Trade-offs

  • Thinner walls hold slightly less heat than the heavy classic
  • Roughly double the classic's price for a Lodge
  • Published weight comes from retailer listings, not Lodge's own spec sheet
MaterialBare cast iron
Diameter10.25 in
Weight3.86 lb
Oven-safe toAny oven temp
Induction-readyYes
Made inUSA
WarrantyLifetime (Made Right)

Spec note. Lodge publishes NO weight for the 10.25-inch Blacklock on its own spec page — only dimensions (17.38 in overall, 2.6 in high) — so every figure in circulation is a retailer's. Retailer listings gave ~3.86 lb on 2026-07-20 and 4.23 lb on 2026-08-31; we keep the earlier figure in the table and state both, because we cannot adjudicate between two retailer numbers. Either way it is well under the classic 10.25-inch's maker-published 5.36 lb, and Lodge's own listing copy claims the line weighs 25% less than traditional cast iron. Thinner walls mean a little less thermal mass than the classic.

Specs read from the manufacturer and product listing, on July 20, 2026. “Not published” means the maker doesn’t state that figure.

#3Closest on surface finish

Stargazer 10.5-inch Cast Iron Skillet

The everyday-size Stargazer, and the one most people who want a machined-smooth pan should look at first. Same polished surface, flared drip-free rim and long stay-cool handle as the 12-inch, in a 5.2 lb body that is barely heavier than a classic Lodge — which is the point.

Strengths

  • Machined-smooth cooking surface, slick from the first cook
  • 5.2 lb — lighter than a 12-inch Lodge and easy to handle
  • Made in the USA with a no-expiration lifetime warranty

Trade-offs

  • Costs roughly five times a classic Lodge that cooks the same food
  • Stargazer publishes no cooking-surface figure, only the 10.5 in rim
  • Still bare iron — the seasoning upkeep does not go away
MaterialBare cast iron
Diameter10.5 in
Weight5.2 lb
Oven-safe toAny oven temp
Induction-readyYes
Made inUSA
WarrantyLifetime (no expiration, defects only)

Spec note. Listing size '10.5 inch', published weight 5.2 lb. Stargazer states the pan is individually cast and machined smooth in the USA, has a flared drip-free rim instead of pour spouts, and carries a warranty with no expiration covering manufacturer defects only. No flat cooking-surface measurement is published.

Specs read from the manufacturer and product listing, on August 11, 2026. “Not published” means the maker doesn’t state that figure.

#4Closest on flat cooking area

Lancaster No. 10 Cast Iron Skillet (11.6-inch)

A big, machined-smooth American pan with an unusually large 10-inch cooking surface for its class — more usable flat space than most 12-inch skillets. A specialist heirloom buy, not a first pan.

Strengths

  • Genuinely large 10-in flat cooking surface
  • Machined-smooth, lighter than a Lodge of similar footprint
  • Made in the USA, heirloom build

Trade-offs

  • Premium price — many times a Lodge
  • Warranty terms aren't clearly published on the product page
  • Big and still six pounds — not a nimble everyday pan
MaterialBare cast iron
Diameter11.6 in
Cooking surface10 in
Weight6 lb
Oven-safe toAny oven temp
Induction-readyYes
Made inUSA
WarrantyNot published

Spec note. Weight 6 lb; the flat cooking surface is about 10 in across, unusually large for an 11.6-in pan. Warranty terms weren't published on the product page at the time of writing.

Specs read from the manufacturer and product listing, on July 20, 2026. “Not published” means the maker doesn’t state that figure.

Frequently asked questions

Is Griswold cast iron better than Lodge?

It is thinner, lighter for its diameter and has a smoother cooking surface than a modern classic Lodge — those three things are real. It is also out of production since 1957, sold secondhand at collector prices, usually in need of restoration, and covered by no warranty at all. A modern Lodge costs about $25, ships pre-seasoned and carries a lifetime warranty. For cooking, the honest answer is that both make excellent food and the differences are smaller than the price gap suggests.

When did Griswold stop making cast iron?

The Erie, Pennsylvania operation ended in 1957. The Wagner and Griswold Society's FAQ records that McGraw Edison bought Griswold on March 29, 1957 and sold it in December 1957 to Randall, which already owned Wagner — after which all subsequent "Griswold" pieces were made in the Wagner foundry in Sidney, Ohio and do not say Erie on them. The society also notes that most collectors do not consider the Sidney pieces real Griswold.

Is a Griswold No. 8 the same as a 10.25-inch skillet?

Close, but bigger. The size chart the collectors' society links publishes a No. 8 skillet as 10.625 inches across the top over an 8.875-inch bottom, 2 inches deep. A classic Lodge 10.25-inch is a little under that at the rim. The numbers were never inches — they are a legacy sizing system, which is why a Lancaster "No. 10" sold new today measures 11.6 inches.

How much should you pay for a vintage Griswold skillet?

We do not publish price guidance for the secondhand market and will not invent it — values move with condition, mark, rarity and the room you are bidding in. What we will say is the structural point: at the common sizes you are usually paying more than a new premium American pan costs, for an item with no warranty, no return and a cleaning job attached. Collector appeal is concentrated in the earlier marks; the society's own FAQ notes almost any piece made after 1960 has limited collector appeal.

Is vintage cast iron thinner than modern cast iron?

Generally yes, and that is the substantive cooking difference. Older pans were cast thinner, so they are lighter for their diameter and respond faster to a change in heat; a thick modern pan stores more energy and recovers better when cold food hits it. Neither is strictly better — thin iron is nimble, thick iron is forgiving. Lodge's own Blacklock line is the modern answer to the first half of that trade.

Do you have to strip and re-season a vintage pan?

Almost always, and that is the hidden cost. A pan that has sat for sixty years arrives with rust, old carbonised fat, or both, and the collectors' society maintains its own cleaning and restoring guidance precisely because this is a project rather than a purchase. Seasoning itself is just polymerized oil bonded to the iron, so a stripped vintage pan and a new pan start from exactly the same place.

Is a smooth vintage cooking surface actually better?

It is nicer for eggs out of the box and it stops mattering once a pebbled pan has built up seasoning, which takes months of real cooking rather than years. The genuinely useful point is that you no longer have to buy old iron to get it: Stargazer machines its cooking surface smooth, Lancaster publishes a 10-inch flat surface on an 11.6-inch pan, and Lodge's Blacklock ships triple-seasoned.

Can you tell a real Griswold from a reproduction?

Sometimes, and it is harder than it sounds. The society publishes a dated trademark chart for Griswold skillets — the slant trademark with ERIE PA USA from about 1909 to 1924, the block trademark from about 1916 to 1940, the small trademark from the late 1930s to about 1952 — and it maintains a dedicated page on reproductions and fakes, which exists because the problem is real. If authenticity matters to the price you are paying, the mark and the date range have to agree with the pan's other features.

What should I buy if I want the vintage feel without the hunt?

A Blacklock if what you want is the weight, a Stargazer or a Lancaster if what you want is the machined surface, and a classic Lodge if what you actually want is a pan to cook in tonight. All three are in stock, warranted, and cost less than a comparable Griswold at auction.

Sources

  • Wagner and Griswold Society — Griswold Skillet Chart (R. G. Meadows, 2017) — The collectors' society's own dating chart for Griswold skillets, crediting Steve Stephens as the primary source for the dates: ERIE first series c1880-c1886, second series c1886-c1892, third series (the first with pattern numbers) c1892-c1905, GRISWOLD'S ERIE c1905-c1907, slant trademark with ERIE c1907-c1909, slant trademark with ERIE PA USA c1909-c1924 (heat ring first, smooth bottom from about 1916), block trademark c1916-c1940, small trademark from the late 1930s to c1952, the late large trademark c1952-1957, and the VICTOR budget line in the 1940s and 1950s (accessed August 18, 2026)
  • Griswold and Cast Iron Information Board (Wagner and Griswold Society) — FAQ — The society's own FAQ, which is the only place it publishes Wagner dates in prose: "Randall Corp. bought Wagner in Nov. 1952"; "McGraw Edison Inc. bought Griswold on March 29, 1957" and "then sold it in December 1957 to Randall who already owned Wagner", after which "all subsequent 'Griswold' pieces were made in the Wagner foundry in Sidney, Ohio" and do not say Erie on the piece; "During the later 1970's and/or early 1980's many pieces were marked with BOTH the Wagner and Griswold trademarks (logos) on the bottom"; "In 1991 a new line of Wagner pieces marked 'Wagner's 1891 Original' was put into production to celebrate Wagner's 100th anniversary. This is the line that remained in production as a regular production item until the foundry closed in 1999"; on numbers, "Each piece of iron has to have its own mold… each pattern has a different letter… after the pattern number which would be the same number for like items"; and on heat rings, "The heat ring is the small rim around the outside of the bottom of many (usually earlier) skillets". It also records the collector view that "Most collectors do not consider Griswold pieces made in Sidney to be real Griswold" and that "almost any pieces made after 1960 has limited collector appeal" (accessed October 11, 2026)
  • panman.com — Cast Iron Skillet and Dutch Oven Size Charts — The size chart the Wagner and Griswold Society links from its own educational page, giving measured top diameter, bottom diameter and depth per number. Skillets: No. 3 = 6.5 in top / 5.25 in bottom / 1.25 in deep; No. 4 = 7 / 5.75 / 1.5; No. 5 = 8 / 6.75 / 1.75; No. 6 = 9.125 / 7.5 / 1.875; No. 7 = 9.875 / 8.25 / 2; No. 8 = 10.625 / 8.875 / 2; No. 9 = 11.375 / 9.5 / 2; No. 10 = 11.75 / 10 / 2.125; No. 11 = 12.5 / 10.875 / 2.125; No. 12 = 13.375 / 11.75 / 2.25; No. 13 = 14.25 / 12.75 / 2.25; No. 14 = 15.25 / 13.5 / 2.25. Dutch ovens: No. 6 = 8.25 in top / 2.5 qt; No. 7 = 9.25 / 3.5 qt; No. 8 = 10.125 / 4.5 qt; No. 9 = 11.25 / 6 qt; No. 10 = 12.25 / 8 qt; No. 11 = 13.25 / 12 qt; No. 12 = 14.25 / 15 qt; No. 13 = 15.25 / 20.5 qt. The chart is tables only — it publishes no explanation of what the numbers represent (accessed October 11, 2026)
  • Wagner and Griswold Society — Cast Iron and Aluminum Care — The collectors' society for Griswold, Wagner and Erie cookware on cleaning and restoring old iron (accessed August 11, 2026)
  • Wagner and Griswold Society — ERIE Skillets, by Roy Meadows — A collector reference on the markings and variations used to identify and date early ERIE and Griswold skillets (accessed August 11, 2026)
  • Lodge Cast Iron — How to Season Cast Iron — Lodge's foundry seasoning method; seasoning is oil baked onto the pan through polymerization; re-season at 450–500°F (accessed July 20, 2026)
  • Lodge Cast Iron — Made Right Warranty — Lodge's stated lifetime warranty terms for its cast iron cookware (accessed August 11, 2026)
  • America's Test Kitchen — The Science of Seasoning — How seasoning forms — oil polymerizing into a hard, plastic-like layer — and how too much heat depolymerizes it (accessed July 20, 2026)
  • C&EN (American Chemical Society) — The chemistry of cast-iron cookware — ACS explainer on seasoning as polymerized oil bonded to the iron surface (accessed July 20, 2026)
  • Stargazer Cast Iron — Use & Care — Stargazer's own maintenance routine: a thin oil coat over low heat after washing, periodic deep seasoning from a 225°F oven, and a high-smoke-point oil such as grapeseed or sunflower (accessed August 11, 2026)
  • Lancaster Cast Iron — First Time Use & Care Guide — Lancaster's own break-in advice: use extra oil for the first dozen cooks, avoid acidic ingredients until the seasoning is developed, dry on low heat and oil while warm (accessed August 11, 2026)

Keep reading